A one-page rate notice from FedEx lands in the same inbox every January. The number has not changed in three years: 5.9%. That number is not your rate increase.
Most operators who ship product have read this memo. They pull the number, plug it into next year's forecast, and move on. That is the standard move: budget for the announced increase. It sounds like planning. It is not. It is anchoring on a number that was designed to be anchored on.
The Mechanism Has a Name
There is a name for this in the literature. In 1998, Vicki Morwitz and two colleagues at NYU Stern published a study called "Divide and Prosper." They tested what happens when a seller splits a total price into a base charge and a set of added fees. The finding was clean. Buyers anchor on the base. They undercount the fees. They walk away thinking they paid less than they did.
That was not a one-off result. In 2026, researchers at Yale and Boston University ran a new test on the same kind of pricing. They found that splitting costs this way leads buyers to overpay by up to 10%. In some cases, 13%. The mechanism Morwitz named 28 years ago still works the same way.
The 5.9% memo does not fail operators. It fails the system they are trying to run.
The Flaw in the Number
The problem is not that the rate increase is high. The problem is that the announced number only covers part of the bill.
The GRI, the General Rate Increase, applies to base transport charges. Surcharges sit on a separate schedule. They move at separate rates. And they move faster.
FedEx raised its residential surcharge 8.4% this year. That is 2.5 points above the announced GRI. The fee itself is $6.45 per package. UPS raised handling fees between 6.6% and 7.3%, depending on zone. FedEx also switched three of its home delivery fees from a per-shipment charge to a per-package charge. A five-box order that once carried one fee now carries five.
The base rate went up 5.9%. The real cost on a typical invoice went up 8% to 12%. For a brand shipping 5,000 residential parcels a month, the residential surcharge increase alone adds roughly $2,500 in monthly cost. Before a single box rolls out the door.
The Carrier Said It Out Loud
This is not a theory built from rate cards. The carrier told its own shareholders.
On its most recent earnings call, a FedEx executive stated they expect "strong capture" on the 5.9% GRI. Same call: the company posted its most profitable peak season on record. FedEx raised its adjusted earnings outlook to $18.00 to $18.60 per share. That is up 23% from the year before.
The gap between what the rate notice says and what the invoice shows is not a rounding error. It is the margin. The carrier is not hiding the mechanism. It is reporting it to Wall Street as a win.
What to Measure Instead
The replacement principle is short. Stop budgeting from the headline. Budget from the invoice.
Once that is clear, three moves follow from it.
Move 1: Run the invoice audit
Pull three months of paid invoices. Add every line: base rate, residential fee, handling fee, dimensional charge. Divide the total by the number of parcels shipped. That gives you a true cost per package. Compare it to the same number from last year. The gap between those two figures is your real rate increase, not the one on the memo.
That step takes about two hours. Most operators who run it find they have been budgeting from a number that understates their actual cost by 30% to 50%.
Move 2: Track surcharges as their own cost line
Stop lumping them into "shipping." Give residential fees, handling fees, and dimensional charges their own rows in your books. When each has its own line, you see which one is growing fastest. The base rate is rarely the answer.
Move 3: Shift carrier talks from base-rate discount to total-cost ceiling
A 20% discount on the base rate sounds good on paper. But if surcharges rise 8% to 12% a year with no cap, the discount shrinks every cycle. The better ask is a ceiling on the total invoiced cost per package, not just the transport line.
What the System Shows
Running this for one quarter does something the announced rate never did.
It shows which surcharge line grew the most since last year. It shows which package types cost the most to ship by actual invoice, not by rate card. It shows whether your carrier discount is holding or leaking. And it shows the real margin the carrier is earning on your account, not the one the rate notice suggests.
Three Questions at the End of the Quarter
At the end of 90 days, ask three things.
→ Which surcharge line moved the most, and by how much?
→ Which cost looked stable on the rate card but grew on the invoice?
→ Which carrier talk focused on the base rate when it should have focused on the total?
That is the difference between a number that sounds right and a system that proves itself.
Free, private email that puts your privacy first
Proton Mail’s free plan keeps your inbox private and secure—no ads, no data mining. Built by privacy experts, it gives you real protection with no strings attached.
Where You Stand
Morwitz named her paper "Divide and Prosper." Twenty-eight years later, the division arrives in your inbox every January. The gap between what they announce and what you pay is not a mistake. It is the architecture.

